Where is it on sale for that much?
Right now, I have found these machines meeting all my musts, in order of most to least interesting, with their key differences.
HP Omen 17 = 144 Hz, i7-9750, RTX 2070, 512GB M.2 for $1650 on Walmart.com.
Alienware M17 = 60 Hz, 8750, RTX 2070 MaxQ, 512GB M.2 for $1500 on Amazon (but Renewed).
Lenovo Legion Y740 = 144 Hz, 9750, 2080 MaxQ, 1TB M.2 for $1800 on Amazon (by Lenovo).
Acer Predator Helios = 144 Hz, 9750, 2070 MaxQ, 512GB M.2, not sure about G-Sync for $1760 on Amazon (by Acer).
I haven't found anything with those specs near those prices for ACER (ConceptD), Gigabyte, XMG (Clevo), or Schenker. Again, no Razers because they don't have a number pad and no ASUS Strix Hero III because there's no camera.
I am shying away from used in general, especially from 3rd party sellers I don't recognize. I am shying away from MSI because of their dual-power and its positioning toward the front - it would have to be significantly better deal than the HP Omen 17 found on Walmart. I am shying away from ASUS because of my current machine's issues and past customer service experience plus their generally higher prices by ~$250 or more.