Lenovo's new ThinkPad X9 is a completely new design and convinces with long battery runtimes as well as an excellent OLED screen. However, Lenovo also breaks with a tradition and does not include a TrackPoint anymore.https://www.notebookcheck.net/Lenovo-ThinkPad-X9-15-Aura-Edition-Laptop-Review-The-MacBook-Air-rival-is-very-good-even-without-a-TrackPoint.967369.0.html
If I bought this Thinkpad, the first thing I would do is send it back. A Thinkpad without a track point is misleading advertising. Call it something else.
Until it has fans it is not a MacBook Air rival.
Any information on Linux (with recent kernel) support?
It would be nice if Notebookcheck would understand the consumer's point of view, not make excuses for manufacturers. Glad you didn't miss the trackpoint, but you probably don't use it that often and it's a totally different input type than a pad. For activities where the cursor is only occasionally moved, the pad is fine, otherwise the only thing better than a trackpoint would be eye or mind control.
Whoever made this abomination should be fired. This will be discontinued within 1-2 generations like the Z series.
Also, they should have marketed this as a ThinkBook since it has that design language instead of a ThinkPad.
Lunar Lake proves intel can match two year old Apple Silicon in battery life, at half the performance and with a robust fan to keep from melting.
Quote from: davidm on February 25, 2025, 16:05:30otherwise the only thing better than a trackpoint would be eye or mind control.
I've heard rumors of a revolutionary new type of pointing device that is under development, and that is vastly superior to both trackpads and trackpoints. They call it a "mouse".
Quote from: Nick Evans on February 25, 2025, 18:25:27I've heard rumors of a revolutionary new type of pointing device that is under development, and that is vastly superior to both trackpads and trackpoints. They call it a "mouse".
Pics or it didn't happen! :P
Not going far enough here Lenovo. Until they decide to remove the trackpoint from every single ThinkPad, I'll continue to personally boycott the brand.
The half-size up/down cursor keys is like a cancer :-( Only gaming models have remained to have useable keyboards these days.
Compared to MacBook Air I'm not sure it's better. I'm pretty concerned about graphics, does it lag when playing block blast (https://blockblastonline.com)?
Great Review, So on the topic of PWM. I have been trying a few OLED Laptops, was very excited for my X9. Opened and used it for 4 day. I cant looked at the screen for more the 5-10 minutes with out have eye pain that last hours. Now i do notice this X9 has 1200hz so now wondering why the screen was bothering my eyes? any help would be great as for it my favorite laptop ever.
Quote from: Joe on February 26, 2025, 11:51:23I cant looked at the screen for more the 5-10 minutes with out have eye pain that last hours. Now i do notice this X9 has 1200hz so now wondering why the screen was bothering my eyes? any help would be great as for it my favorite laptop ever.
1200 Hz is high enough, typical mobile screen has around 250 Hz only. There may be a diferent issue. The display resolution (density) is quite low for a 15" screen (I'd accept 4K at least) and OLED use different subpixel matrix than LCD screens that looks more unreadable in low resolutions. I've seen a 1920x1200 15" OLED that was absolutely awful, there were always red shadows next to white text on black background as a result of the low resolution and different subpixel matrix. I wasn't able to use it at all. 4K screen was ok, as the resolution is high enough to hide it.
Quote from: Nick Evans on February 25, 2025, 18:25:27Quote from: davidm on February 25, 2025, 16:05:30otherwise the only thing better than a trackpoint would be eye or mind control.
I've heard rumors of a revolutionary new type of pointing device that is under development, and that is vastly superior to both trackpads and trackpoints. They call it a "mouse".
A mouse is not superior to a trackpad. It's probably the most primitive. Having to move a significant part of your body just to move a pointer, something people might do many times a minute, is absurd. Not to mention needing a desk layout and having to carry another thing. Of course, it depends what's being done. But for software dev, the trackpoint is best, even with a mostly keyboard driven workflow. I guess that notebookcheck's perspective is becoming gamerz, so I can't speak to that. I guess spending days running around in a dark tunnel with a schlong^wweapon in front of you, a mouse would be better.
Its not a thinkpad without a trackpoint. They can call it whatever they want but its just not. Its just using the brand name to sell a notebook. Its bad enough they got rid of dual battery systems with hot swapping.
Ugly rebadged Ideapad.
Lenovo=Chinese junk.
It is not just the track point that is missing... There is literally nothing left of what a Thinkpad is supposed to be:
Lousy keyboard ergonomics, tiny keystroke, half arrow keys...
Glossy screen full of reflections
Non upgradable internal components
And last but not least.. no trackpoint.
You can shove it up your @rse Lenovo
Quote from: Puppy on February 26, 2025, 15:57:38Quote from: Joe on February 26, 2025, 11:51:23I cant looked at the screen for more the 5-10 minutes with out have eye pain that last hours. Now i do notice this X9 has 1200hz so now wondering why the screen was bothering my eyes? any help would be great as for it my favorite laptop ever.
1200 Hz is high enough, typical mobile screen has around 250 Hz only. There may be a diferent issue. The display resolution (density) is quite low for a 15" screen (I'd accept 4K at least) and OLED use different subpixel matrix than LCD screens that looks more unreadable in low resolutions. I've seen a 1920x1200 15" OLED that was absolutely awful, there were always red shadows next to white text on black background as a result of the low resolution and different subpixel matrix. I wasn't able to use it at all. 4K screen was ok, as the resolution is high enough to hide it.
Subpixel rendering should not be used on OLED screens because they are usually designed for LCD subpixels and may cause weird colored artifacts around text. It's nice that Windows allows you to configure the type and parameters of text rendering on each display separately.
My laptop has an 15.6" OLED screen where pixels are so dense that the type of rendering doesn't make much difference, though. Text is always extremely sharp so that you can physically approach the screen to read tiny text, e.g., in PDFs, instead of zooming in.
How does the Haptic trackpad on the X9-15 compare to the Haptic trackpad on the X9-14? I've read that the one on the X9-14 is much better than the one on the X9-15, but I'm not sure how or why. I'm hoping to hear comments from someone who has personally used both varieties of Haptic trackpad. Thank you.
Aside from the horrible keyboard I'm tempted which is a bit concerning
Quote from: Randy on February 25, 2025, 17:49:42Lunar Lake proves intel can match two year old Apple Silicon in battery life, at half the performance and with a robust fan to keep from melting.
It would be bad if a tablet processor that can't run many desktop applications doesn't get good battery life.
Put hx 370 or strix halo in something like lenovo z16 gen 3, then I might switch back from macbook. I can't even do anything with those f* intel e cores.
Is the slight decrease in performance with respect to the 14-inch[1] mainly due to the differences in power fed to the CPU?
If so, any insights as to why Lenovo might be constraining power more on the larger device?
[1] "www.notebookcheck.net/Closest-Windows-competitor-to-the-MacBook-Air-13-Lenovo-ThinkPad-X9-14-laptop-review.979149.0.html"