Quote from: Bernie Pechlaner on February 27, 2017, 03:53:53
It wouldn't have had much of an impact, as a lot the scores are calculated automatically based on the test data entered.
As an owner of quite a few different notebooks (Lenovo, HP, Asus, Dell - including some ancient ones as well which I can't seem to part with), I try to be as fair as possible.
Bernie
Bernie
There is a big, big mistake on the evaluation of the display, the contrast of the display you measured is actually 1200:1 rather than 700:1.
Let me explain: for some reason there is an adaptative brightness mechanism on this notebook, however it adapts very slowly (within 15 seconds). This means when you measure black levels coming from a brighter APL, you will grossly overestimate them (therefore underestimating contrast).
You need to set a latency time of 15 seconds in your measurements and measure a constant APL greyscale OR measure an ANSI pattern.
It took me a while to figure this out, but when you come from a dark content to white or near white, it takes a long time for the brightness to pick up. This is supposed to avoid eye-strain.
Likewise, when you move from bright content to a black or near black content, it takes time for the display to dim.
However what matters here is intra-picture contrast or constant APL contrast, as this allows you to find out how good each individual picture of a video or content will look like. An ANSI pattern gives you the contrast and brightness at an APL level of 50% white.
This is why subjectively you found the display attractive but your low contrast measurement unfairly decreased the overall mark for this FANTASTIC laptop.
I myself ALMOST did not buy this laptop because of the 700:1 contrast you measured. You ABSOLUTELY need to correct this and give it the excellent overall score it deserves (and as someone pointed out, you can set up the right click zone, keyboard and touchpad are the best on the market right now for me, I play video games on this laptop and the tactile feedback is nothing short of amazing compared to a MacBook or other competing devices). For me the only thing preventing it from getting perfect marks is the older generation NVIDIA, but the laptop is such a joy to use, I really don't mind for a multimedia laptop.
Another note about the display - the lower priced model has an inferior display, also calibrated to 1250 contrast but with lower peak brightness (270cd/m²). No matter what APL level I used I was not able to trigger a higher brightness level and I am wondering if this is a software limitation as I can find none of the dynamic brightness mechanism on this particular model! The contrast and colors are very good but maximum brightness is limited (even after deactivating auto dimming and setting brightness to 100%).
It seems the more expensive version having the pen is pushed as a device for artists and therefore brightness is better accommodated. I have ordered a replacement for the cheaper variant and will report if I observe the same behaviour again.