Quote from: WayneN on March 19, 2016, 05:40:51
Nice review. But, I do agree with the sentiment in earlier comments that the score is too high. I had the chance of using both the T450s and E7450 and the Dell flagship can get 8+ hrs on battery while T450s can only pull 5 hrs without an extended battery. They had the same specs and same usage patterns. It seems Lenovo only improved 1 hr for T460s but 6 hrs is barely cutting it - pretty mediocre for today's standards.
Splitting the battery in 2 adds a second point of failure and you can't replace the battery easily. I imagine 1 battery will wear out first if no wear leveling is used. Also the PWM is a huge con if you have to be at 90% brightness all the time to avoid flicker. This just depletes battery even faster.
The Thinkpad wins for the keyboard and trackpoint for sure but the E7450 had a brighter screen, more rigid construction imo, 8+ hrs with standard battery and 3 year NBD warranty included. Anyway, I think the T450s and T460s were over-scored. I'm looking forward to see what Dell does with the E7470.
I'm compelled to agree. Even though I love my T450s dearly, there are clear flaws with the screen (I got the AUO panel, which, though not significant, does have slightly warmer colours compared to my XPS 13), the bending of the screen (which is quite significant and distorts the backlight), and the soldering of the RAM. An HDMI port would also have been appreciated.
In the case of the T460s, the PWM, lacking brightness, soldered RAM, and two battery design WITHOUT hot swap should not give it a higher rating than the T460s. However, I think all of the business laptops are slightly overscored.
I'd put the E7450 and the T450s at around the same footing, but maybe bring them down 1-2%. I'd lower the T460s to 1% below the T450s (as the keyboard is apparently worse... Too many sacrifices for less weight)